Connect with us

86th TX Lege

Texas LGBTQ Caucus Marks Major Victory, Killing Bill They Feared Would Hurt Gay People

The LGBTQ Caucus, formed this year, notched a major victory Thursday evening, defeating a controversial measure as the Texas House raced toward a midnight deadline.

Published

on

“We’re getting things done, and we’re here to stay,” state Rep. Julie Johnson, D-Carrollton, said of the House LGBTQ Caucus. Photo credit: Emree Weaver/The Texas Tribune

This article originally appeared in The Texas Tribune

In their first major test, members of the Texas House’s LGBTQ Caucus helped muscle down a bill Thursday night that they characterized as an assault on gay rights and protections.

The five female lawmakers in the first-of-its-kind caucus used a parliamentary maneuver to delay and ultimately defeat House Bill 3172 by Fort Worth Republican Matt Krause, a measure he said would protect religious individuals and organizations from attacks by the government, and authorize the Texas attorney general to bring lawsuits in their defense.

With the Texas House racing toward a midnight deadline to consider its bills, state Rep. Julie Johnson, a Carrollton Democrat and longtime trial lawyer, rose with a “point of order” — a procedural technicality aimed at delaying or killing a bill. It was shot down. But she had a second point of order up her sleeve, and this one — to the surprise of many — stuck. While it’s possible Krause’s measure could get amended to another piece of legislation in the waning days of the legislative session, the clock has run out for this particular bill.

“The LGBTQ Caucus is in the House,” Johnson said in an interview on the House floor shortly after the bill was defeated. “We’re getting things done, and we’re here to stay.”

The defeat of Krause’s bill — which many LGBTQ advocates considered the most serious threat to reach the House floor this session — took less than an hour. And it marked a major shift in tone in a chamber that has been less conservative since the 2018 midterms. This session, pro-LGBTQ measures have made unprecedented progress in the Republican-majority Texas House, earning debate in committees for the first time — though few, if any, are expected to become law. The death of Krause’s bill was particularly striking given how close a highly controversial “bathroom bill” got to becoming law during the last legislative session.

“This commonsense religious freedom effort is far from over. We will not allow the clear will of the majority of Texans and a bipartisan majority of the Texas Legislature to be thwarted by a few,” said Jonathan Saenz, president of Texas Values Action.

By the time Krause’s bill reached the House floor, it had already been significantly watered down. That followed a late-night committee hearing that drew passionate opposition from the LGBTQ community. As presented Thursday, the bill would have prevented government entities from taking “adverse action” against individuals or organizations based on their “membership in, affiliation with, or contribution, donation, or other support provided to a religious organization” — protections that, in large part, are already enshrined in current law. Some groups, such as Texas Impact, a faith-based organization that opposes discriminatory measures, removed their opposition to the bill after its toughest language was stripped out.

But LGBTQ advocates and lawmakers still feared the bill could be amended or restored to its original version in a messy floor fight — particularly in the more socially conservative Texas Senate, which has already passed a so-called religious refusals law.

Krause said he would not have allowed additions from either chamber, and added he was disappointed that the House did not get the chance to debate his bill, especially after the revised measure stripped out so much of the language that caused advocates concern.

“Not only was there no discriminatory intent, there was no discriminatory language,” Krause said. “There was no discriminatory possibility with this bill. We worked very hard to make sure that was the case.”

Krause’s bill would also have allowed the Texas attorney general to sue state employees or government entities to force them to comply with the measure. That provision would have laid the groundwork for Attorney General Ken Paxton to sue San Antonio, a city that has often drawn the ire — and the litigation power — of his office. Paxton launched an investigation into the City Council’s decision earlier this year to keep Chick-fil-A from opening a restaurant in the city’s airport. One council member, Robert Treviño, asked to block the franchise from a slate of contracts, saying he could not support a company with “a legacy of anti-LGBTQ behavior.”

Supporters of the Krause bill had lauded its potential to “#SaveChickFilA.” The interest group Texas Values — best known for leading the charge for the “bathroom bill” that dominated Capitol conversations in 2017 — had worked to drum up support for the Krause proposal at a “Save Chick-fil-A” advocacy day at the Capitol in April, an all-day affair that began with a lunchtime rally and ended in the early hours of the next morning in a committee hearing packed with witnesses.

The Texas Tribune is a nonpartisan, nonprofit media organization that informs Texans — and engages with them – about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.

Emma Platoff is a breaking news and civil courts reporter at The Texas Tribune, where she started as a fellow in 2017. She is the first to fill either role. A recent graduate of Yale University, Emma is the former managing editor of the Yale Daily News and a former intern at The Philadelphia Inquirer and the Hartford Courant.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Comments
Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Special Preorder Price

november 2019

18nov(nov 18)10:00 PM19(nov 19)2:00 AMMartinis & KaraokeHosted by Danny Pintauro10:00 PM - 2:00 AM (19) Rain on 4thCategories:NightlifeAges:21+

18nov(nov 18)10:00 PM19(nov 19)2:00 AMGame Night10:00 PM - 2:00 AM (19) Oilcan Harry'sCategories:NightlifeAges:21+

18nov(nov 18)11:00 PM19(nov 19)2:00 AMAustin’s Next Drag SuperstarHosted by Nadine Hughes11:00 PM - 2:00 AM (19) Sellers UndergroundCategories:DragAges:21+

19nov6:00 PM8:00 PMTuesday Night Run6:00 PM - 8:00 PM The Rock at Town LakeCategories:RunningAges:All Ages

19nov6:45 PM10:30 PMVarsity Gay League Austin Kickball Fall 2019 Season6:45 PM - 10:30 PM Krieg Softball ComplexCategories:KickballAges:21+

19nov7:00 PM9:00 PMTuesday Social TennisHosted by Austin Tennis Club7:00 PM - 9:00 PM Austin Tennis CenterCategories:TennisAges:All Ages

19nov7:30 PM9:30 PMVolleyball Austin Open Play7:30 PM - 9:30 PM Austin Sports CenterCategories:VolleyballAges:All Ages

19nov8:00 PM11:00 PMTexas Hold'em TournamentHosted by Wild West Casino Games8:00 PM - 11:00 PM The Iron BearCategories:NightlifeAges:21+

19nov8:00 PM9:15 PMAustin Naked YogaTaught by Daryn8:00 PM - 9:15 PM ToddPilates & Barre North AustinCategories:FitnessAges:18+

19nov8:30 PM10:30 PMAustin Pride Bowling League8:30 PM - 10:30 PM Dart BowlCategories:BowlingAges:All Ages

19nov(nov 19)9:00 PM20(nov 20)12:00 AMMagical Musical Showtune Sing-AlongHosted by Brian Hall9:00 PM - 12:00 AM (20) Oilcan Harry'sCategories:DragAges:21+

19nov(nov 19)9:00 PM20(nov 20)12:00 AMDrag Class: Semester 8Hosted by Sabel Scities9:00 PM - 12:00 AM (20) Rain on 4thCategories:DragAges:18+

19nov(nov 19)10:00 PM20(nov 20)2:00 AMTuezGayzFeaturing theGlitoris10:00 PM - 2:00 AM (20) Barbarella AustinCategories:NightlifeAges:21+

19nov(nov 19)10:00 PM20(nov 20)2:00 AMKiki & KaraokeHosted by Nadine Hughes & Adam Stone10:00 PM - 2:00 AM (20) Sellers UndergroundCategories:NightlifeAges:21+

20nov6:00 PM9:00 PMTransgender Day of Remembrance6:00 PM - 9:00 PM TownLake YMCACategories:LGBTQ+Ages:All Ages

20nov6:00 PM8:00 PMSteak Night6:00 PM - 8:00 PM BT2 AustinCategories:Food,NightlifeAges:21+

20nov7:00 PM10:00 PMQueer Ride7:00 PM - 10:00 PM Texas State CapitolCategories:CyclingAges:All Ages

20nov7:00 PM10:00 PMTexas Hold'em TournamentHosted by ADA Hold'em7:00 PM - 10:00 PM Detour Neighborhood Bar DomainCategories:NightlifeAges:21+

20nov(nov 20)9:00 PM21(nov 21)2:00 AMWerqHosted by Diamond Dior & Scarlett Kiss 9:00 PM - 2:00 AM (21) Sellers UndergroundCategories:DragAges:21+

20nov9:00 PM10:30 PMTough Titty TriviaHosted by Miss Chaise Lounge9:00 PM - 10:30 PM Stonewall WarehouseCategories:DragAges:21+

Advertisement
Advertisement

X